Why Didn’t It Happen Sooner?

One of the guys made fun of the conversation I’d begun: a bunch of men sitting around, so of course the conversation would turn to sports.

But my purpose really was to touch on deeper matters.

I’d started with field-goal kicking. All of us — ranging in age from late 70s to late 80s — had grown up in a world where field-goal kickers came straight at the ball and kicked it with their toes. (Same with kick-offs.) But then — in the 1960s — there came someone named Pete Gogolak from the world of soccer who approached the ball from an angle and kicked the ball with his instep. He began doing this in professional football with the Buffalo Bills in 1964, and joined the NFL’s New York Giants in 1966. For a time he was unusual in the professional football world, but it wasn’t very long before virtually every field-goal kicker in the league was kicking in that new fashion.

A sports story, to be sure. But what interested me was that a whole nation of many millions had been doing things one way for generations, and all of a sudden there was a new way of doing it that quickly became universal.

That new way had always been available — no great technological breakthroughs were needed to make it possible. Not like the iPhone, which could never have been invented even by clever people like Eli Whitney or Thomas Edison — never, because probably hundreds of other things would have needed to be invented first. The foot that Gogolak used for his soccer-style kick was basically the same as the feet that charged up San Juan Hill, not to mention the much more ancient feet that left footprints preserved in volcanic ash at Laetoli in Tanzania. The innovation was there for the taking, but football players were born and died without anyone coming upon this available and superior technique.

Much the same happened with high-jumping. When I was briefly a competitive high-jumper, I was taught the Western Roll. I was given the impression this was a new technique — an improvement over the technique, still attempted by a few of my adolescent competitors, of just trying to jump over the bar the way you might try to leap over a fence. Those guys never won, because the Western Roll was a way of getting PART of the body over the bar (with one’s lead leg) and then the rest over by kicking the trailing leg before the knee could knock the bar off the supports. At the highest levels of competition, variations on the roll and straddle techniques dominated for decades.

But it seemed that almost overnight, those established techniques became obsolete.

Soon after my high-jumping days were over, a fellow named Dick Fosbury began developing a new technique that looked ridiculous but had the singular virtue that it was a winner. The “Fosbury Flop” involved approaching the bar at an angle, turning one’s back to it, arching backward over it head and shoulders first, and finally kicking the legs up and over. Fosbury won Olympic gold with it in 1968.

Again, there was nothing about this technique — now used by virtually all the world’s great high-jumpers — that required some new way of moving the human body. (Safer foam landing pits did help make it practical.) High-jumping had been part of the modern Olympics since the first Games in 1896. Presumably, many thousands of young men — and their coaches — were motivated to win their competitions. But necessity did not give birth to that invention for all those years until Fosbury came along.

Something similar can happen not only in how we do things physically, but also in how we think about what we’re doing.

It used to be, in the NFL, that when you got to 4th down, you almost always punt.

If you’re close enough to the opponent’s end zone, the punt wouldn’t do much good and a field goal is possible. If you’re backed up too close to your own end zone, you can’t afford to gamble on giving the opponent the ball so close to their touchdown territory. But in some vast midfield region, if you don’t get a first down in the first three plays of the series, you punt.

Almost every team I ever saw chose to punt almost every time under such circumstances. But no more.

Now, on fourth and fairly short, teams are routinely going for it in situations where they almost never went for it before.

Again, the basic arithmetic behind these fourth-down decisions was available for coaches to do over the many decades that went before: the decision to punt was pretty automatic. Now, in the same situation, coaches are making a different decision. Why?

It’s not clear — as far as I can see — that the chances of making it have changed enough to explain the shift. So if the current decisions are wise, how did it become almost universal practice to make the unwise decision? And then how did the conventional wisdom get changed?

What these examples show in the world of sports, I imagine, could be shown throughout the realm of human endeavor. How many ways of doing things, accepted as natural or inevitable, might turn out to be inferior to alternatives that have been available all along?

We’ve no reason to believe ourselves different from the people who kicked footballs and jumped over bars before Gogolak and Fosbury. They were doing what generations of people before them had learned to do.

What improvements in our world might remain unmade, not because we lack the means to achieve them, but because we have mistaken “that’s how it’s always been done” for “that’s the best way to do it”? How much better might we make our world if we put more creativity to work discovering better ways of doing things?

 

Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *