Trump and the Lie

Trump and the Lie

I would bet heavily that no person has had so much attention from the American people in its history as Donald Trump. I’d even bet that no one in all of human history has so dominated the attention of the world as Trump over the past decade. He shows a real genius for getting attention.

Another bet I’d make, though not as heavily, is that no one in American history has had so large an impact on the nation (not even Washington, Lincoln, and FDR) as Trump. I think it unlikely that I’ll live long enough to see all the damage that he inflicted on the country repaired.

One more bet I’d make: Trump’s psychology has been more difficult to get clear about than just about any other major historical figure, even in comparison with other hugely impactful Men of Brokenness like Stalin and Hitler.

Add to those factors that “political psychology” is an area in which I’ve written and published for more than forty years, and the result is that I have invested a huge amount of time and effort over the past decade seeking to understand this extraordinary man.

The Narcissistic Lie

Trump has widely been recognized as a narcissist. And the psychological structure essential to narcissism provides a key that can help us understand this extraordinary man.

The key lies in recognizing that at the foundation of narcissism is a Lie the narcissist tells himself. And we can see how that foundational Lie provides Trump with the basis on which he builds his relationship with the world—a world in which Lies reign.

The Lie begins with a profound psychological injury. A child who is subjected to abusive treatment by someone who has power over him, and who treats him as if his needs don’t matter, can come to feel utterly powerless and worthless.

The narcissist defends himself against that intolerable experience by constructing a false picture of himself: not worthless, but extraordinarily important; not powerless, but superior to others. His grandiosity is the opposite of the painful feelings buried beneath it.

But the Lie doesn’t heal the original injury. It merely covers it over. And because the underlying feelings remain, the narcissist must continually defend the grandiose self-image against anything that threatens to expose the wounded self beneath.

We know plenty about the kind of abusive human being Trump’s father was. Trump’s niece, Mary Trump, a psychologist, has described a terrible family dynamic in which Fred Trump divided the world into Winners and Losers, and treated weakness with contempt. Donald’s older brother, Mary’s father, was subjected to repeated humiliation by their father, and eventually drank himself to death.

Donald grew up watching what happened to the son who failed to meet his father’s demands. We can readily imagine how determined he became never to be the Loser, never to be the one in the weaker position. He must always declare his own GREATNESS, always be the Big Deal. Beneath that grandiose self-image lies the injury inflicted on a child who came to experience imposing his own dominance—and making someone else the weak one—as the only alternative to being the one whose needs didn’t matter at all.

It’s a basic Lie: acting like he feels so strong, when he’s never healed from the injuries inflicted on him when he was in the weaker position in relation to an abusive parent.

Trauma prevents the two contradictory parts of the narcissist’s picture of himself from coming together and reconciling into something whole and true, rather than broken and built upon the Narcissistic Lie. Reconciliation would mean recognizing: “You are a human being with VALUE, AND you’re just part of a larger picture of others who are also of value.”

But so great is the chasm between the initial traumatic humiliation and the compensatory insistence upon one’s greatness (“I know more about war than the generals”) that the two cannot be brought together into that Truth, where people are more than Winners and Losers, the great and the contemptible.

Turning Reality into Its Opposite

That narcissistic Lie provides the basic structure on which Trump has built much of his way of dealing with the world. What begins as a false picture of himself provides the template for other lies that serve the same purpose as the original one: fashioning a false reality that serves his psychological needs and gets him what he wants.

Just as the original Narcissistic Lie declares the very opposite of the inward experience of worthlessness—“I am GREAT”—so Trump’s other Lies follow the same pattern: turning reality into its OPPOSITE.

Trump’s famous Big Lie, for example, was that he had the 2020 election STOLEN from him. But the truth, demonstrated time and again, was that Trump had lost the election fair and square. And the one trying to STEAL the election was the one crying “Thief!” himself.

Likewise, Trump dismisses the criminal indictments brought against him after extensive investigations as politically motivated—a corrupt “weaponization” of the Justice Department. Yet those prosecutions arose from evidence of serious alleged crimes, and failing to investigate such evidence would itself have raised questions of dereliction of duty.

Meanwhile, upon returning to power, Trump has turned his own Justice Department into a weapon against his political enemies. Again and again, grand juries have rejected his efforts to prosecute those enemies, while judges have condemned the politically motivated use of prosecutorial power.

The same reversal runs through both examples. The man accused of wrongdoing presents himself as its victim, while accusing those who oppose him of committing the very wrongs attributed to him. “I’m not the wrongdoer. YOU are. You’re not the victim. I AM.”

The original Narcissistic Lie—“I’m not the Loser. YOU are”—has become a pattern for turning the roles of perpetrator and victim into their OPPOSITES.

When the Liar Believes His Own Lies

So profound does Trump’s dependence on falsehood seem to be that the question arises whether he himself believes in the false picture he seeks to sell to the nation.

Trump’s Big Lie about the 2020 election provides a particularly revealing case through which to explore that question.

For a long time, I assumed that Trump knew perfectly well when he was lying. And I still believe that was true when, beginning in June 2020, he visibly began laying the groundwork for claiming that the coming election would be rigged. Over the following months, he repeatedly claimed, without evidence, that mail-in voting—which was expected to favor Biden—would invite widespread fraud. Apparently foreseeing the possibility of defeat, he was preparing the ground for declaring an election he’d lost to have been stolen from him.

But I came increasingly to believe that something changed after he actually lost.

What gradually changed my mind was watching Trump’s extraordinary inability to let go of the 2020 election. Month after month, year after year, he continued insisting that the election had been stolen from him. Even after he regained the presidency four years later, he kept returning to the subject.

It took me well over a year to become convinced that Trump had come to believe the very Lie he’d originally devised to deceive his followers. What had begun as an effort to persuade them that he—and therefore they—had been robbed seemed to have become something he himself needed to believe.

I came to think that admitting defeat was simply an indigestible truth for Trump. It meant acknowledging himself as a LOSER, compelled to yield to the WINNER—recapitulating the traumatic circumstance in which his original narcissistic injury had been inflicted. Even his refusal to attend Biden’s inauguration seemed an expression of his inability to accept the reality that someone else had defeated him.

And now, when we hear Trump repeatedly declare that we’ve already WON the war against Iran—a war in which it has seemed clear to experts since early in the conflict that the United States would lose much and gain next to nothing—it again seems quite possible that he actually believes that Emperor Trump’s New Clothes are the finest we’ve ever seen.

Malignant Narcissism

There are many narcissists in the world, with fragile egos and a need to ward off feelings of inferiority and worthlessness. But among psychologists who have attempted to understand Trump, there is a widespread characterization of his particular KIND of narcissism as MALIGNANT.

What this means is that the narcissistic need is combined with a predominantly destructive set of motivations: to gain power over others, to use that power to create conflict and division, and to subject others to cruel and humiliating treatment.

Not all narcissists are malignant. And not all narcissists crave power. Not all narcissists are so defended that their contact with reality is quite unreliable. When all three combine in someone who succeeds in gaining the power they crave, the consequences can be destructive on a scale commensurate with the range of those powers.

The Lie as Trump’s Weapon of Choice

Trump’s dependence on the Lie was not merely a psychological necessity. It became his most important instrument for acquiring political power. Other would-be tyrants have relied principally on force. Trump, however, rose to power through his extraordinary ability to persuade people to believe things that were demonstrably false. His repeated business failures did not prevent him from creating an image of himself as an immensely successful businessman. Through that deceptive show of success, he helped establish the public image that would eventually carry him toward the most sought-after position of power in America.

The Lie was central to his political ascent from the beginning. He gained political prominence by spreading the Birther Lie, questioning whether Barack Obama was legitimately President of the United States. He launched his presidential campaign by portraying Mexican immigrants as criminals and rapists, although the crime rate among immigrants was lower than that of the American population generally. And still later came the grotesque falsehood about Haitian immigrants eating people’s pets. These were not simply lies about particular people or events. They were lies designed to make people afraid, to direct their fear into hatred of designated enemies, and to make them look to Trump as their protector.

His lurid picture of “American Carnage”—at the center of his first inaugural address—portrayed a nation besieged by crime and disorder. His promise to “Make America Great Again” offered himself as the strong leader who could rescue it. Together, the frightening picture and the promise of national restoration helped build a movement powerful enough to place him in the White House, where he would seek to undermine the democratic institutions and the rule of law that had been central to America’s greatness.

And when Trump lost the 2020 election, the Lie became his weapon for denying the legitimacy of the democratic process itself. Despite the repeated disproof of his claims, he persuaded a large majority of Republican voters that the election had been stolen. The extraordinary thing is not merely that Trump told such lies, but that he could get so many people to believe them. Whatever explains that remarkable capacity, it amounts to a kind of genius for wielding the Lie as an instrument of political power.

The Force of Brokenness

The Lie that began as one child’s defense against an unbearable truth has spawned an endless procession of offspring, now pouring from the bully pulpit of the American Presidency and flooding the nation’s political life with confusions and deceptions—like the multiplying broomsticks and their buckets of water in Disney’s FANTASIA.

The man who speaks for the nation, commanding its attention more constantly and completely than perhaps any President before him, makes continual pronouncements astonishing for their almost complete lack of truth value.

And the man entrusted with making decisions of enormous consequence is so committed to preserving his false picture of reality that he cannot reliably see the world as it is, or anticipate the consequences of his actions.

When that dishonesty and detachment from reality are joined to the destructive impulses of malignant narcissism, the Lie becomes more than a means of protecting a wounded ego. It becomes a powerful weapon on behalf of the Force of Brokenness—the same force that, decades ago, worked through a father to inflict a psychological wound upon his child, and now, through that child become President, turns the United States—once called “leader of the free world,” and “the world’s indispensable nation”—into an agent of tyranny, corruption, and environmental destruction.

 

Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *